I'm not sure which one to go for! Thinking MPG alone.

2010 1.6 TDi Zetec S (Old shape) Urban: 50.4mpg

2011 1.6 Zetec Petrol (New shape) Urban: 35.3mpg

I do town miles, prob go on the motorway once a week, but I'm a fast driver (rarely do 30-40)

I have a 2009 1.8 TDi Titanium now... Urban is 42.0mpg but I get 29.9mpg so I know what it says isn't correct anyway

Any help would be great!
People who have the above? Tell us how you drive and what mpg it states?

Thanks

Personally I'd say the diesel, but this model is fitted with a DPF, so make sure you give it a good kicking for a constant 10-15 mins on the motorway to clear out any carbon build up, to keep the DPF in good working order. I currently have the 1.8tdci, and my urban is around 31-33, but then I do drive on the eco side lol.