Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Green Cotton Vs Kn Induction Filter
Ford Owners Club - Ford Forums > Ford Models > Ford Focus Club
footfistart
Does anyone know if that discount still works on pri racing for the green cotton filter? I'm only asking as there are a couple of kn filters on eBay and I am wondering if they are any good compared with the green cotton. As the green cotton has only 60,000 mile warranty and kn has a million mile.

So my question is has anyone used both of these filter and is there a diffence between the two?

Many thanks
artscot79
panel filter or induction filter? panel filter then they are both good induction filter i wouldnt even put one on unlless you want less power
footfistart
It's a cone type filter ie the e-2993 part number from on. Less power how come? Due to the fact that the engine would need to be 're calibrated? I assume that would be right but I would of thought that it would help a little bit by being less restrictive so that the turbo has a bit more of a chance to spool up better without strain of my right foot :)
k13r4n
When you put an air filter on it obv increases air intake but also adds hot air from the engine bay to the cold air coming in hence the decrease in power
Lenny
[quote name='footfistart' timestamp='1359652201' post='231971']
It's a cone type filter ie the e-2993 part number from on. Less power how come? Due to the fact that the engine would need to be 're calibrated? I assume that would be right but I would of thought that it would help a little bit by being less restrictive so that the turbo has a bit more of a chance to spool up better without strain of my right foot :)
[/quote]
Ive never used a K&N but Green argue that their filters are better because they dont use machines to bond them like K&N
Green show K&N filters with glue covering the edge on the cotton restricting flow,
Green dont have this problem.

And to confirm,
If using your existing air box enclosure,
An upgrade induction filter will help both performance and mpg.
But if removing the air box enclosure to fit an exposed induction filter, then these suck in heat, but panel/air box filter upgrade is a good option.
And as far as im aware Ross at pri racing still has the exclusive offer of 10% off
See my fitting guide for the discount code.

Or if you really want to maximise induction, You could fit a K&N 57s system consists of bigger air box lid to house supplied bigger fiter plus optional cold feed side inlet port. Im tempted myself http://www.autospecialists.co.uk/KNs-57S-Performance-Airbox-Lid--Performance-filter-upgrade---57S-4000-Product-1131.html

[IMG]http://i575.photobucket.com/albums/ss192/lennymanwoods/imgsize.jpg[/IMG]

Here are some pictures of the edge on the green filter, no glue smear.

[IMG]http://i575.photobucket.com/albums/ss192/lennymanwoods/Image2395.jpg[/IMG]

[IMG]http://i575.photobucket.com/albums/ss192/lennymanwoods/Image2392.jpg[/IMG]
footfistart
Wow thanks guys been a great help. Well I'm a kn fan as I had a big cone style on my fiesta and having that helped the car a lot. Dunno about power but fuel economy went up a he'll of a lot. Same driving and I could get 430 miles instead of 300 and to make it better it wasa fiver of eBay :) my fiesta was a 1.25 16v.
I may go with kn and perhaps getting the deep airbox for it also.

One thing I have noticed it that the snorkel. It stretches right across the front upper grill. Not sure whether to adjust it to suit. As looking at it you can take it off and looks like you get a stumpy snorkel intake. Whther that would make any difference at all who knows. There's a few kns on eBay for focus rs or the Volvo c30/v40 as the use the same filter plus having a million mile warrenty I may as well go with kn.

By the way it will be all enclosed as I don't fancy sucking hot air in. Defeats the idea of having an intercooler does it not lol :)
btmaldon
Just to throw a spanner in the works, I have been getting better performance from a Pipercross panel filter than I did the K&N one in my previous car that had the same engine. This just feels smoother and revs more freely.
footfistart
Really? Significant difference or just feel? I think I'll go for k&n I've used them before and and friends use them and can't fault them.
Is yours just a standard car or have you mapped it so you do feel difference? If that makes sense. I'm not mapping mine as warranty :( but being a 1.6 it's hardly worth it due to updating the clutch and what not....
Lenny
[quote name='footfistart' timestamp='1359752177' post='232348']
Really? Significant difference or just feel? I think I'll go for k&n I've used them before and and friends use them and can't fault them.
Is yours just a standard car or have you mapped it so you do feel difference? If that makes sense. I'm not mapping mine as warranty :( but being a 1.6 it's hardly worth it due to updating the clutch and what not....
[/quote]
Sorry to take this slightly off topic,
But i have my focus 1.6TDCi remapped last June from 90bhp to 120bhp
Havent heard anything about the clutch though, is their an upgrade available or where can i read some more information on this please.

As for the snorkle,
Some people remove it,
Ive still got mine in place but i did have the slam panel removed for a couple of weeks, while the slam panel was being colour coded i noticed a deeper roar from the engine and slightly more response due to the slam panel being removed.
I imagine the same results would be achieved by removing or modifying the snorkle.
If you have a dremil,
You could cut the long snorkle in to a wide angle scoop forcing air in from the front.

[IMG]http://i575.photobucket.com/albums/ss192/lennymanwoods/Image2429.jpg[/IMG]

[IMG]http://i575.photobucket.com/albums/ss192/lennymanwoods/Image2426.jpg[/IMG]
footfistart
Well my focus is a 110 1.6 and I have another topic going which is about dpf removal and people were mentioning about the clutch and upgrading it. Can't really remember what was said but if you have a read up people were saying about different clutches and saying that my original one won't last if I was to remap it.

And snorkel well I'm sure I am able to modify by using the orignal plastic scoop and perhaps aiding the intake and try and turn it into a ram air. If I do so then no more puddle splashing :( lol.
btmaldon
[quote name='footfistart' timestamp='1359752177' post='232348']
Really? Significant difference or just feel? I think I'll go for k&n I've used them before and and friends use them and can't fault them.
Is yours just a standard car or have you mapped it so you do feel difference? If that makes sense. I'm not mapping mine as warranty :( but being a 1.6 it's hardly worth it due to updating the clutch and what not....
[/quote]
With the K&N I didn't find any significant difference to the standard but I notice some with the Pipercross. The car is standard otherwise. I doubt in reality that there is much difference between any of them, it comes down to personal preference. I would say however the K&N filters are better quality.
Lenny
[quote name='footfistart' timestamp='1359797732' post='232477']
Well my focus is a 110 1.6 and I have another topic going which is about dpf removal and people were mentioning about the clutch and upgrading it. Can't really remember what was said but if you have a read up people were saying about different clutches and saying that my original one won't last if I was to remap it.

And snorkel well I'm sure I am able to modify by using the orignal plastic scoop and perhaps aiding the intake and try and turn it into a ram air. If I do so then no more puddle splashing :( lol.
[/quote]
Thanks mate will look in to it,

Regarding the existing snorkle,
Perhaps unplug it
Flip 180 degrees
Plug it in again
Then cut it off just inside the grill
Resulting in an extended front facing feed.
footfistart
No worries.... Oh yeah that sounds like a plan I'll try that. Even when it comes to selling it there cheap as chips to get a new snorkel.
But like I say I'm a kn fan and I've got one on the way. So I'm hoping with will make some sorta difference. Still save money when it comes to service time as its one less thing to buy/pay for.

What sorta mpg do you get standard. I get 61 and that's motoway and town driving. And to add to that... I only do 35 mile round trip to work. And that's not really driving like a granny lol. And what about your tuned 120hp Kenny? Any difference in the mapping? Economy wise?
Lenny
[quote name='footfistart' timestamp='1359811640' post='232522']
No worries.... Oh yeah that sounds like a plan I'll try that. Even when it comes to selling it there cheap as chips to get a new snorkel.
But like I say I'm a kn fan and I've got one on the way. So I'm hoping with will make some sorta difference. Still save money when it comes to service time as its one less thing to buy/pay for.

What sorta mpg do you get standard. I get 61 and that's motoway and town driving. And to add to that... I only do 35 mile round trip to work. And that's not really driving like a granny lol. And what about your tuned 120hp Lenny? Any difference in the mapping? Economy wise?
[/quote]
61mpg is very good mate im Currently getting 1284km/798miles per 55ltr fill of Diesel thats around 88.3kpg or 55mpg on premium fuel
Thats with a 2.5" DPF back duplex exhaust, Green Cotton Induction filter, and ECU Remap.
Mostly motorway driving but does the school run mon-fri two weeks out of three.
I probably could get better kpg/mpg if i set my alarm early enough in the mornings for work lol
61 is very impressive though.
Im considering upgrade to focus 110 injectors, said to improve acceleration ànd may improve mpg too.
footfistart
oh really?? was it better than 55mpg before you got all of that done was that the reason why you went ahead with those mods.

theres a few people on turbo diesel owners club who have the 90hp and put the 110 injectors in when remapping. seem to get good power from doing so.

yeah my car is doing 61mpg now and during the summer i get anything from 62-66mpg. not bad really. i just thought try something cheap and chearful to help the car along. and soon enough it will eventually pay for its self :) all being well lol
salsheikh
i only get about 35 mpg as mine is mainly driving thru traffic in town about 15 miles. i then have a few trips in the day to pick kids up so again its very short journeys - less than 3 miles.
motorway wise, the best i've had is 60mpg as i did 60mph all the way to the outlaws (approx 120 miles).
if i was getting anything above 45mpg in town i'd be really chuffed.

Ryan, i too have a k&n to fit, just cleaned and oil it and may fit it tomorrow.
Lenny, my decat is booked in for Weds AM (gonna get the stuffing knocked out and getting an EGR blank fitted) and the rear silencer has gone too. strangely, the exhuast note sounds like a 5 pot!
footfistart
35! My god that is poor well not suprising due to short journeys. Better off with a petrol. I bet your car doesn't even warm up in that time. Mine takes about five mins to warm up well by water temperature and about ten mins in the crap cold weather.

Oh really yeah fit it as I'd like to know what you think of it and I'll do the same when mine arrives. I managed to get mine for 35squids :)
As you mentioned Egr valve.... Where is it. I've had a look but I'm not really sure where it is. Is it round the back of the engine like the earlier models as in around 05. As mine is a 60plate I guess I'd have a slightly different engine as mine I think is a Euro5. I think not sure how to tell the difference between 4 and 5. But yeah anyways EGR valve.....

Is it worth me blanking it up to preserve it or leave it until it decides to break? If it's not broken don't fix it... As everyone seems to say but I like to think ahead with things. So good idea or bad.... If good where can I get a stainless plate from?
If bad I'll leave it be :)
Lenny
[quote name='footfistart' timestamp='1359825261' post='232565']
oh really?? was it better than 55mpg before you got all of that done was that the reason why you went ahead with those mods.

[/quote]
Yes i used to get around 62mpg before the remap and exhaust but change of job left me closer to work than before so i got in to engine modifications then, because i could live with the decrease in Mpg but it didnt drop like i was expecting it to, and the car feels much better, have you driven a 90 model compared to your 110 theirs a big difference in pick up.
Lenny
[quote name='salsheikh' timestamp='1359829576' post='232589']
i only get about 35 mpg as mine is mainly driving thru traffic in town about 15 miles. i then have a few trips in the day to pick kids up so again its very short journeys - less than 3 miles.
motorway wise, the best i've had is 60mpg as i did 60mph all the way to the outlaws (approx 120 miles).
if i was getting anything above 45mpg in town i'd be really chuffed.

Ryan, i too have a k&n to fit, just cleaned and oil it and may fit it tomorrow.
Lenny, my decat is booked in for Weds AM (gonna get the stuffing knocked out and getting an EGR blank fitted) and the rear silencer has gone too. strangely, the exhuast note sounds like a 5 pot!
[/quote]
Sounds good mate,
Be sure to start a thread on this and some pictures,
Im sure your turbo will spool much quicker with no restrictions,
2.5 inch pipe would also help
footfistart
No I haven't been in any other diesel. The closest I've been to a 90hp tdci is my girlfriends dad cmax. And that's all that. My car has more oooomph than that thing. Yeah deffs mate I'll make a thread. I don't know how to though. How do you? Is it same as making a new topic or different? I reckon it would spool much better which would be nice as I do have a flat spot around 1600 to about 1900rpm.

Do you know where the egr valve is? I want to blank it off to help more.
What do you think or anyone who is following this knows?
Lenny
[quote name='footfistart' timestamp='1359844313' post='232653']
No I haven't been in any other diesel. The closest I've been to a 90hp tdci is my girlfriends dad cmax. And that's all that. My car has more oooomph than that thing. Yeah deffs mate I'll make a thread. I don't know how to though. How do you? Is it same as making a new topic or different? I reckon it would spool much better which would be nice as I do have a flat spot around 1600 to about 1900rpm.

Do you know where the egr valve is? I want to blank it off to help more.
What do you think or anyone who is following this knows?
[/quote]

Yeah the cmax engine at 90 would be much the same as the focus was lol
New topic is the same as a new thread mate,
Egr location, i dont know to be honest,
But egr blanking,
Purchase a stainless steel blanking plate,
Because other types get hot,soften and break through, resulting in metal fragments passing throught the egr system.
Stoney871
The EGR should be at the rear of the engine linked between the exhaust and inlet manifolds.
Usually a large steel tube with load of pipes branching in and out of it.
Lenny
[quote name='Stoney871' timestamp='1359879469' post='232683']
The EGR should be at the rear of the engine linked between the exhaust and inlet manifolds.
Usually a large steel tube with load of pipes branching in and out of it.
[/quote]
Exhaust manifold on the 1.6TDCi is at the front and egr should be to the front left.
But i dont know which pipe to block etc.

[IMG]http://i575.photobucket.com/albums/ss192/lennymanwoods/Image1654.jpg[/IMG]
Stoney871
This is what the valve looks like-

http://pages.ebay.com/link/?nav=item.view&id=321020374643

It sits on the end of a cooler unit like this-

http://pages.ebay.com/link/?nav=item.view&id=251173206081
footfistart
Oh i see.....said the blind man..... the next time ill be able to get my head under the bonnet is on wednesday as thats when i come off shift. i work 8am to 8pm four on four off so i need daylight. but hopefully by then my Kn should arrive and i can fit that and then create a thread of that for other people including the snorkel mod before and after pics and what not. thanks for your help again. i think ill make my own blanking plate. theres loads of stainless on ebay. if i can get the sizes then ill be able to make one :) i take it yours insnt blanked either??
footfistart
Right update time!!!

Kn filter arrived and fitted.
will be making a thread tomorrow as putting pics via phone proofs abut difficult. Plus I've carried out another mod to the induction as you will all find out :)
salsheikh
[quote name='footfistart' timestamp='1360253451' post='233975']
Right update time!!!

Kn filter arrived and fitted.
will be making a thread tomorrow as putting pics via phone proofs abut difficult. Plus I've carried out another mod to the induction as you will all find out :)
[/quote]

looking forward to the thread Ryan.


This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2014 Invision Power Services, Inc.